Midjourney V6 vs DALLE-3 Text Prompt COMPARISON (Print on Demand Ai Art Faceoff)
TLDRThis video presents a detailed comparison between Midjourney V6 and DALLE-3 AI art generators using nine distinct prompts for print on demand. The evaluation criteria include graphic quality, suitability for printing, and text accuracy. Both tools were tested for their adherence to prompts, with side-by-side comparisons in Adobe Illustrator. While Midjourney offers vibrant colors and an artistic vibe, DALLE-3 excels in following prompts and text accuracy. The face-off is a draw until the final round, where DALLE-3 takes a slight edge for its suitability in print on demand, despite Midjourney's fast generation capabilities. Viewers are encouraged to score each round and share their preferences in the comments.
Takeaways
- 📊 The video compares MidJourney V6 and DALL-E 3 across nine different print-on-demand prompts.
- 🧀 Round 1: DALL-E 3 followed the prompt better with more joyful cheese characters and correct spelling, winning this round.
- 🐨 Round 2: MidJourney spelled 'quality gains' correctly and had a more aesthetically pleasing design, making it the winner.
- 👱♀️ Round 3: DALL-E 3 produced a simpler, more accurate design with correct text spelling, winning this round.
- 🍕 Round 4: MidJourney created a better-looking design despite not following the cartoon prompt well, winning this round.
- 🦉 Round 5: MidJourney had a more vintage look and correct spelling, winning this round.
- 🦝 Round 6: DALL-E 3 had a more suitable design for print-on-demand with correct spelling, winning this round.
- 🥑 Round 7: DALL-E 3 depicted a more realistic avocado and had a better overall design, winning this round.
- 🌞 Round 8: MidJourney created a more visually appealing design with correct spelling, winning this round.
- 🏄♂️ Round 9: DALL-E 3 produced a more suitable design for print-on-demand despite some text issues, winning this round.
- 🏆 Overall, DALL-E 3 was deemed slightly more suitable for print-on-demand designs, but both tools have their strengths.
Q & A
What was the purpose of the face-off between Midjourney V6 and DALLE-3?
-The purpose of the face-off was to compare the two AI tools, Midjourney V6 and DALLE-3, based on their ability to generate graphics for print on demand, considering factors such as the quality of graphics, suitability for print, and accuracy of text spelling in the images.
How was the face-off conducted between the two AI tools?
-The face-off was conducted by giving both Midjourney and DALLE-3 the same text prompt, running it multiple times, and then selecting the top two results from each tool. These results were then compared side by side in terms of graphics quality, adherence to the prompt, and text accuracy.
What was the first prompt given to both AI tools, and how did they perform?
-The first prompt was for a cartoon-style image with various types of cheese characters and the phrase 'Cheese the day, carp brium.' Midjourney's results were more artistic but did not follow the cartoon style prompt well, while DALLE-3 stayed closer to the prompt but had spelling issues in the text.
How did Midjourney V6 handle the spelling of the phrase in the first prompt?
-Midjourney V6 did not handle the spelling of the phrase well, with 'cheese the da' and 'day' being the only recognizable parts, and the rest of the sentence was lost. There were also spelling errors like 'Carper briam Bri' and 'carpet'.
What was the second prompt, and how did DALLE-3 perform in comparison to Midjourney V6?
-The second prompt was for a 2D flat design featuring a koala lifting a massive dumbbell with the text 'Quality gains.' DALLE-3 performed better in terms of depicting the koala working out and having a more flat design, but it could not spell the text correctly, unlike Midjourney which spelled 'quality gains' correctly.
Which AI tool won the first round, and why?
-DALLE-3 won the first round because it followed the prompt better, had correct spelling in the text, and produced graphics that were more joyful and playful as per the prompt's requirement.
What was the prompt for round three, and what were the key differences in the results?
-The prompt for round three was for a 2D flat color drawing of a stylish girl with a distinctive messy bun hairstyle, wearing a bandana with a pink leopard pattern, and the text 'Mom of a warrior' in a handwritten font. Midjourney's results were more detailed and artistic, while DALLE-3's were flatter and more cartoonish, with correct spelling but less detail.
Which tool was more accurate with text spelling in the early rounds, and why might that be important for print on demand?
-DALLE-3 was more accurate with text spelling in the early rounds. Accurate text spelling is important for print on demand because it ensures that the final product is professional and meets customer expectations, avoiding any potential misunderstandings or dissatisfaction.
What was the prompt for round four, and how did Midjourney V6 and DALLE-3 differ in their interpretations?
-The prompt for round four was for a flat 2D cartoon graphic of a pizza and a beer with the text 'Pizza and beer' in a clear outline isolated on a white background. Midjourney V6's interpretation was less cartoon-like and more detailed, while DALLE-3 produced a more simplistic, fun, and playful design that was more in line with the cartoon theme.
Which tool won the fourth round, and what were the deciding factors?
-Midjourney V6 won the fourth round. The deciding factors were the correct spelling of the text and the aesthetic appeal of the design, which was more suitable for print on demand despite not strictly following the 'cartoon' aspect of the prompt.
What was the general outcome of the face-off after all rounds, and what does this suggest about the suitability of each tool for print on demand?
-After all rounds, DALLE-3 was slightly more suitable for print on demand according to the video creator's opinion. This suggests that while both tools have their strengths, DALLE-3's style and text accuracy might be more aligned with the needs of print on demand, although Midjourney V6 also has the capability to generate a lot of graphics quickly.
Outlines
🎨 Graphic Design Comparison: Mid Journey V6 vs D E3
This paragraph introduces a comparative analysis between two graphic design tools, Mid Journey V6 and D E3, across nine different prompts. The focus is on evaluating the quality of graphics for print on demand, the adherence to prompts, and the accuracy of text spelling in the images. The method involves giving both tools the same prompt, running each multiple times, and selecting the top two results to compare side by side in Adobe Illustrator. The first prompt is for a cartoon style image with various types of cheese characters and the phrase 'cheese the day carp brium'. Mid Journey's results are noted for their artistic vibe and color, but they do not strictly follow the cartoon style prompt. D E3's results are more joyful and playful, aligning better with the prompt, and also have better text spelling accuracy.
🏋️♂️ 2D Flat Design Showdown: Koala with Dumbbells
In the second round, the prompt is for a 2D flat design featuring a koala lifting a dumbbell with the text 'quality gains'. Mid Journey's results are more detailed and less flat, not strictly adhering to the prompt's 'flat design' requirement, but the text is spelled correctly. D E3's top result captures the workout vibe better and has a more appropriate flat design, although it fails to spell the text correctly. The narrator expresses a preference for Mid Journey in this round due to correct text spelling and appealing graphics, despite the prompt adherence issue.
👩🦱 Messy Bun Style Showdown: Flat Color vs. Artistic Detail
The third round's prompt describes a 2D flat, color drawing of a stylish girl with a messy bun hairstyle, wearing a bandana with a pink leopard pattern and matching sunglasses, with the text 'mom of a warrior'. Mid Journey's results are more detailed and artistic, while D E3's are flatter and more cartoonish. Both tools have minor issues with spelling accuracy, but D E3's text layout and adherence to the prompt's style are preferred, making it the winner of this round according to the narrator.
🍕 Pizza and Beer: A Clash of Cartoon Styles
In the fourth round, the prompt is for a flat 2D cartoon graphic of a pizza and a beer with the text 'pizza and beer'. Mid Journey's result, while aesthetically pleasing for print on demand, does not closely follow the 'cartoon' aspect of the prompt. D E3's result is more cartoonish and playful, aligning better with the prompt, but suffers from spelling errors. The narrator awards this round to Mid Journey due to better adherence to the print on demand aesthetic and correct text spelling, despite the prompt interpretation issue.
🦉 Wise Owl Vintage Showdown: Colorful Vectors vs. Textured Artistry
The fifth round's prompt calls for a colorful vector illustration of a comical owl wearing glasses with a vintage sunset theme and the text 'Wise Owl wisdom'. Mid Journey's results offer a vintage, textured, old-fashioned effect, while D E3 focuses on the colorful aspect with a more symmetrical and cleaner layout. Both tools correctly spell the text, but D E3's slight spelling issue and the preference for the vintage feel lead the narrator to favor Mid Journey for this round.
🦝 Raccoon in Sunglasses: Vaporwave Aesthetics
In the sixth round, the prompt is for a vaporwave-themed t-shirt design featuring a raccoon wearing sunglasses with the text 'I eat trash'. Mid Journey's result has plain colors and a raccoon that is not easy to work with for print on demand due to detail complexity. D E3's result is cleaner, more suitable for print on demand, and has the text spelled correctly, making it the preferred choice and the winner of this round according to the narrator.
🥑 Avocado Sign Holder: Suitability for Print on Demand
The seventh round presents a prompt for a flat vector ad graphic of an avocado holding a sign with the text 'AO nice day'. Both Mid Journey and D E3 provide good results, but Mid Journey's text size and placement make it less readable. D E3's design is more suitable for print on demand, with a realistic sign-holding avocado and a sticker-like feel. The narrator prefers D E3 for this round due to its suitability for print on demand and better text presentation.
🌊 Good Vibes Typography: Distressed Effects
In the eighth round, the prompt is for a simple 'Good Vibes only' typography design in a rough distressed font. Mid Journey applies the distressed effect to the entire image, while D E3 focuses on the text. Both designs are appealing, but the narrator leans towards Mid Journey for this round due to cooler and more intriguing fonts that are easier to read, despite the prompt interpretation discrepancy regarding the 'script font'.
🏄♂️ Vintage Surfboard Design: Print on Demand Suitability
The final round's prompt describes a 2D flat drawing of a vintage distressed graphic design featuring a surfboard with the text 'dad who loves surfing'. Mid Journey's interpretation includes surfboards in the sea with a square graphic, while D E3's design aligns more with typical vintage sunset designs seen on print on demand websites. Both tools have minor issues with text size and accuracy, but D E3's design is deemed more suitable for print on demand, leading the narrator to award this round to D E3 and declare it the overall winner of the comparison.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Midjourney V6
💡DALLE-3
💡Print on Demand
💡Text Prompt
💡Cartoon Style
💡Spelling Accuracy
💡Illustrator
💡2D Flat Design
💡Stylized
💡Vintage Sunset
💡Typography
Highlights
Midjourney V6 and DALLE-3 were compared for nine different print on demand prompts.
Graphics were evaluated on visual appeal, suitability for print on demand, and text accuracy.
Both AI tools received the same prompt and the top two results were compared.
Midjourney's results were on the left, and DALLE-3's on the right for side-by-side comparison.
The first prompt involved cartoon-style cheese characters with the phrase 'cheese the day'.
Midjourney favored artistic style over prompt adherence, while DALLE-3 stayed closer to the prompt.
DALLE-3 had better text accuracy but included unrelated text in one graphic.
Prompt number two featured a koala lifting a dumbbell with 'quality gains' text.
Midjourney's text was spelled correctly, but design was not as flat as prompted.
DALLE-3 depicted a more accurate workout scenario but with spelling errors.
Round three's prompt was a stylish girl with a messy bun and 'mom of a warrior' text.
DALLE-3's designs were flatter and more suitable for print on demand.
Midjourney's text was almost correct, but DALLE-3 had better text layout and spelling.
Round four's simple prompt was 'pizza and beer' with a clear outline on white background.
Midjourney's design was good for print on demand, but DALLE-3 had spelling mistakes.
Round five depicted a comical owl with 'wise owl wisdom' text in a vintage sunset setting.
Midjourney had a more vintage feel, while DALLE-3 focused on colorful and symmetrical design.
DALLE-3 had a minor spelling issue, but Midjourney's vintage style was preferred.
Round six's prompt was a vaporwave-themed t-shirt with a raccoon and 'I eat trash' text.
Midjourney's design was detailed but difficult for print on demand, while DALLE-3 was cleaner and more suitable.
DALLE-3 won round six for better text readability and design suitability for print on demand.
Round seven featured an avocado holding a sign with 'AO nice day' text.
DALLE-3's design was more realistic and suitable for print on demand, winning this round.
Round eight's prompt was 'Good Vibes only' in a rough distressed font.
Midjourney's design had a cool texture effect, but DALLE-3's was harder to read.
Midjourney won round eight for better font choice and readability.
The final round featured a surfboard with 'dad who loves surfing' in a vintage distressed style.
DALLE-3's design was more typical for print on demand, winning the final round.
DALLE-3 was slightly more suitable for print on demand overall, but Midjourney has its benefits.
The comparison showed a close race, with DALLE-3 winning by a narrow margin.