创成式AI填充工具对决！收费Photoshop beta对决免费AI工具ClipDrop！哪款更好用？ Adobe Photoshop VS. free AI tool ClipDrop !

靜電的AI設計教室
20 Jun 202309:25

TLDR在本期视频中，主持人静电对比了Adobe Photoshop Beta版本的AI创成式填充功能与免费的AI工具ClipDrop。通过三组图片的测试，包括插画、人物照片和风景照片，比较了两款工具的outpainting功能。ClipDrop虽然免费但生成的结果有时会出现不可预知的元素，而Photoshop Beta则提供了更高质量的图片和更高的自由度，允许用户通过关键词自定义填充内容。最终，Photoshop Beta在图片质量和精准度上胜出，尽管需要付费，而ClipDrop则以其免费的优势吸引用户。

Takeaways

  • 😀 The video compares the AI outpainting capabilities of Adobe Photoshop beta and the free AI tool ClipDrop.
  • 🔍 Both tools are tested using the same three images: an illustration, a real person photo, and a landscape photo.
  • 🆓 ClipDrop is a newly released tool by Stability.AI and is free to use, offering AI-driven image enhancement and background extension.
  • 🔄 ClipDrop provides four different outpainting results for each image, and users can generate additional sets if needed.
  • 🤔 ClipDrop's outpainting sometimes introduces unpredictable elements and can be hit-or-miss in terms of quality.
  • 😮 In one of the tests, ClipDrop humorously added an unexpected 'boyfriend' to a couple's photo, showing the potential for surprises with AI.
  • 🖼️ Adobe Photoshop beta offers a more controlled outpainting experience with the ability to use keywords for customization.
  • 💰 Photoshop beta's results are generally more precise and of higher quality compared to ClipDrop, but it comes at a cost.
  • 🌟 The video showcases how Photoshop can generate images with specific elements, like flowers and trees, when prompted with keywords.
  • 📈 The comparison highlights the trade-off between quality and cost, with Photoshop being superior in quality but ClipDrop being free.
  • 👍 The presenter, Diànjìng, recommends viewers to choose the tool based on their needs and praises both for leaving a strong impression.

Q & A

  • 创成式AI填充工具是什么？

    -创成式AI填充工具，也称为AI边缘填充或generative fill功能，是一种利用AI技术在图片边缘进行预测式填充的工具，用来补全图片的缺失部分或未知部分，通常可以用于创造具有创意的图片内容。

  • ClipDrop和Photoshop Beta版本的AI创成式填充功能有什么不同？

    -ClipDrop是Stability.AI推出的免费AI工具，它通过AI驱动来增强现有图片或照片，改变图像的纵横比。Photoshop Beta版本是Adobe推出的收费工具，它提供了更高精度的图片生成和更多的自定义选项，如使用关键词来描述填充内容。

  • ClipDrop的AI填充功能有哪些特点？

    -ClipDrop的AI填充功能可以生成扩展背景来增强现有图片，提供多组不同的填充结果供用户选择，并且它是完全免费的。但有时生成的图片可能会出现不可预知的元素。

  • Photoshop Beta版本的AI创成式填充功能有哪些优势？

    -Photoshop Beta版本的AI创成式填充功能提供了更高的图片精准度和质量，用户可以通过输入关键词来自定义填充内容，适合专业设计师使用。

  • 在测试中，ClipDrop和Photoshop Beta版本分别使用了哪些类型的图片？

    -在测试中，ClipDrop和Photoshop Beta版本都使用了三张不同类型的图片：一张插画图片、一张真实的人物照片和一张风景照片。

  • ClipDrop在测试中的表现如何？

    -ClipDrop在测试中的表现有好有坏。在第一组和第三组测试中，ClipDrop生成的图片边缘填充稍显复杂，有时会出现奇怪的元素。但在第二组测试中，ClipDrop给了观众一个惊喜，生成了一张非常和谐且有趣的图片。

  • Photoshop Beta版本在测试中的表现如何？

    -Photoshop Beta版本在测试中的表现相对稳定，没有出现翻车的情况。它生成的图片质量较高，且可以通过关键词来自定义填充内容，适合需要更高精度和定制化的用户。

  • 如何获取Adobe Photoshop Beta版本？

    -获取Adobe Photoshop Beta版本的方式可以在静电之前的视频里找到，或者点击视频下方的介绍区查看获取方式。

  • ClipDrop和Photoshop Beta版本在价格上有何不同？

    -ClipDrop是完全免费的AI工具，而Photoshop Beta版本作为Adobe的产品，是需要付费使用的。

  • 根据视频内容，你认为哪款工具更适合设计师使用？

    -根据视频内容，Photoshop Beta版本由于其高精度的图片生成和自定义关键词功能，更适合专业设计师使用。

  • 视频最后提到的AI绘画课程是什么？

    -视频最后提到的AI绘画课程是由静电推出的，内容包含丰富的干货知识，具体的报名方式可以在视频介绍区找到。

Outlines

00:00

💬 Introduction and Overview of AI Tools

The speaker introduces themselves and their channel, discussing the growing number of AI tools with generative fill functions available on the market. They aim to compare the quality and usability of the paid Photoshop beta version's AI generative fill feature with the free AI tool ClipDrop. The concept of outpainting, which fills the edges of an image using AI, is explained, and the speaker sets up a test using three images (an illustration, a real person photo, and a landscape photo) to compare the two tools. ClipDrop, a new tool from Stability.AI, is introduced as a free AI-driven image editing tool similar to Photoshop's generative fill.

05:01

🔍 Testing and Comparing AI Tools

The speaker demonstrates the use of ClipDrop, starting with importing an image for edge filling and adjusting the image's aspect ratio. ClipDrop provides four different fill results per attempt. They observe that ClipDrop generates complex images with unpredictable elements. The second test photo shows an unexpected figure in the generated image, leading to humorous commentary. The third test involves a landscape photo, with ClipDrop producing some unsuitable results initially but eventually generating acceptable ones. The speaker summarizes ClipDrop's performance as mixed, with some impressive and some less satisfactory outcomes.

🖌️ Exploring Photoshop Beta's Generative Fill

The speaker transitions to testing Photoshop Beta's generative fill feature. They explain the process of importing an image, using the crop tool to expand the canvas, and selecting the area for outpainting. Photoshop offers the option to generate fills with or without custom keywords, providing greater flexibility than ClipDrop. In their tests, Photoshop consistently produces high-quality, appropriate images without unexpected elements. The speaker highlights the ability to use keywords to influence the generated content, demonstrating this with examples involving flowers and trees.

🏆 Final Comparison and Conclusion

The speaker concludes the comparison by summarizing the results from both tools. Photoshop Beta's generative fill is praised for its precision and quality, though it requires a paid subscription. ClipDrop is noted for its accessibility as a free tool, despite its occasional production of unpredictable results. The speaker encourages viewers to choose the tool that best fits their needs. They also mention the launch of an AI drawing course and invite viewers to check the video description for more details. The video ends with a request for likes, subscriptions, and follows, and a sign-off from the speaker.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI Edge Filling

AI Edge Filling, also known as generative fill, is a feature that uses artificial intelligence to predict and fill in the missing or unknown parts of an image. In the context of the video, this technology is central to the comparison between Photoshop beta and ClipDrop, as both tools are evaluated on their ability to enhance images by extending or filling in the edges. For instance, the script mentions how AI can be used to creatively expand classic memes beyond their frames.

💡Outpainting

Outpainting is a specific application of AI Edge Filling where the AI predicts and fills in the areas outside the boundaries of the given image. It's a technique that can be used to extend the image creatively or to complete missing parts. The video script discusses how both Photoshop beta and ClipDrop utilize outpainting to generate new content beyond the edges of the original images, which is a key aspect of the comparison.

💡Photoshop beta

Photoshop beta refers to a version of Adobe Photoshop that is still in the testing phase. In the video, it is one of the two tools compared for its AI-driven outpainting capabilities. The script highlights that Photoshop beta offers a high degree of precision and quality in the images it generates, although it comes at a cost.

💡ClipDrop

ClipDrop is a new, free AI tool introduced by Stability.AI, which is similar to Photoshop's generative fill feature. It is designed to enhance existing images or photos by generating and expanding the background, thus changing the aspect ratio of any image. The video script showcases ClipDrop's performance in outpainting, noting that while it is free, it sometimes produces unpredictable elements in the generated images.

💡Image Quality

Image Quality is a critical measure in the video's comparison, as it assesses the effectiveness of the AI tools in generating high-quality outpainting results. The script discusses how the quality of the filled areas impacts the usability of the final images, with examples provided from both Photoshop beta and ClipDrop's outputs.

💡Aspect Ratio

Aspect Ratio refers to the proportional relationship between the width and height of an image or screen, which is important when discussing how AI tools like ClipDrop can change the dimensions of an image. In the script, it is mentioned that ClipDrop allows users to adjust the aspect ratio, thereby enabling the AI to generate new content that fits the desired dimensions.

💡Customization

Customization is highlighted in the video as a feature of Photoshop beta that allows users to input keywords to guide the AI in generating specific content. This feature provides a higher level of control over the outpainting process, as demonstrated when the script describes adding keywords like 'flowers' to influence the generated image.

💡Surprise Elements

Surprise Elements in the context of the video refer to unexpected or unusual results generated by the AI tools. The script humorously points out an instance where ClipDrop added an unexpected person to a合影 (group photo), which, while surprising, did not necessarily align with the desired outcome.

💡Free Tool

A Free Tool, as mentioned in the video, is a software application that is available at no cost. ClipDrop is described as a free AI tool, which is a significant advantage for users who may not want to or cannot afford to pay for software like Photoshop beta. The script contrasts the free nature of ClipDrop with the paid option of Photoshop beta.

💡AI Product Comparison

AI Product Comparison is the overarching theme of the video, where the host,静电 (Static Electricity), compares the features and performance of two AI-driven image editing tools. The script details a head-to-head test between Photoshop beta and ClipDrop, evaluating their capabilities in outpainting and overall image quality.

Highlights

市面上带有AI边缘填充功能的AI产品越来越多

收费的AI工具与免费工具在出图质量上的比较

Photoshop beta版本与ClipDrop工具的功能对决

AI创成式填充功能介绍，即outpainting功能

ClipDrop是Stability.AI推出的免费AI修图工具

ClipDrop通过AI技术扩展背景增强现有图片

ClipDrop提供4组不同的填充结果供选择

ClipDrop生成的边缘填充图像稍显复杂

ClipDrop在人物合影中生成了意外的第二个男人

ClipDrop在风景照中生成了奇怪的人物

Adobe Photoshop Beta版本提供更高的图片精准度

Photoshop Beta版本允许使用关键词自定义填充内容

Photoshop Beta版本生成的图片质量比ClipDrop更高

Photoshop Beta版本没有出现ClipDrop的翻车情况

Photoshop Beta版本与ClipDrop的图片生成对比

Photoshop Beta版本需要付费，ClipDrop免费

根据需求选择Photoshop Beta或ClipDrop

AI绘画课程上线，提供丰富的干货内容

Casual Browsing

Stable Diffusion"手撕" Midjourney？免费AI绘画工具上线Discord，9个对比揭晓谁更强！Free SDXL1.0 VS Midjourney，who's Best?

2024-05-21 08:20:02

【AI】2024年最强AI视频生成工具TOP 5，其中三款完全免费

2024-05-21 06:35:01

不花钱替代Midjourney ！这个AI绘画工具免费又超级好用！A free and easy-to-use MidJourney alternative

2024-05-21 07:00:02

真的有用！2024年還在用的AI工具✨ChatGPT Photoshop Midjourney Google Bard

2024-05-19 06:10:02

Quick demo of the ClipDrop plugin for Adobe Photoshop

2024-05-20 14:55:02